Handwriting Analysis: Fact or Fiction? What Science Says

Have you ever wondered if your loopy L's or slanted T's could reveal hidden aspects of your personality? Also known as graphology, the centuries-old practice...

Have you ever wondered if your loopy L’s or slanted T’s could reveal hidden aspects of your personality?

Also known as graphology, the centuries-old practice of handwriting analysis claims to unlock the secrets of our personalities through the strokes of our pens.

But is there any truth to these claims, or is it just another pseudoscience? Let’s dive into the fascinating world of handwriting analysis and separate fact from fiction.

What is Handwriting Analysis?

Handwriting analysis, or graphology, is the study of handwriting to determine a person’s personality traits, emotional state, and potential behaviors.

Graphologists claim they can deduce various characteristics about an individual by examining factors such as:

• The slant of letters
• The size and shape of letters
• The pressure applied to the paper
• The spacing between words and lines
• The way certain letters are formed

While it might sound like a modern-day personality test, handwriting analysis has a long and colorful history dating back centuries.

A Brief History of Graphology

The roots of handwriting analysis can be traced back to the 17th century when Italian physician Camillo Baldi published the first known book on the subject.

However, it wasn’t until the late 19th and early 20th centuries that graphology gained popularity thanks to figures like Jean-Hippolyte Michon, who coined the term “graphology,” and Ludwig Klages, who developed it into a more systematic approach.

Throughout the 20th century, graphology found its way into various fields, including:

• Criminal investigations
  • Analyzing ransom notes and threatening letters
  • Attempting to create criminal profiles based on handwriting
  • Comparing suspect’s handwriting to crime scene evidence
• Personnel hiring processes
  • Screening job applicants for personality traits
  • Assessing potential employees for leadership qualities
  • Attempting to predict job performance and fit
• Psychological assessments
  • Complementing traditional psychological evaluations
  • Claiming to reveal hidden personality traits
  • Assessing emotional states and mental health
• Even matchmaking services!
  • Comparing handwriting samples of potential partners
  • Claiming to predict compatibility based on writing styles
  • Offering personalized relationship insights through handwriting analysis

But as the scientific method became more rigorous, handwriting analysis faced increasing scrutiny. So, that brings us to the next section…

What Does Science Say About Handwriting Analysis?

When it comes to handwriting analysis, the scientific community is, well, not exactly writing home about it. Let’s break down what researchers have discovered:

Lack of Empirical Evidence

Despite its long history, handwriting analysis has struggled to gain scientific credibility. A comprehensive review of research spanning decades found little evidence to support the claims made by graphologists.

More specifically, it was found that laymen and psychologists without a background in graphology performed just as “well” as graphologists when it came to making inferences about an individual based on their handwriting.

Across all raters, correlations between judgments and actual personality measures were low, leading the authors to conclude that the validity as a tool for personality assessment is questionable at best.

The Barnum Effect

Many of the “insights” provided by handwriting analysis can be attributed to what psychologists call the Barnum Effect.

This is our tendency to accept vague, general personality descriptions as uniquely applicable to ourselves. It’s the same principle that makes horoscopes seem eerily accurate!

In the context of handwriting analysis, this means that people might readily accept broad statements about their personality based on their handwriting, even if those statements could apply to almost anyone.

Inconsistent Results

Studies have shown that different graphologists often come to different conclusions when analyzing the same handwriting sample.

This lack of consistency raises serious questions about the reliability of the practice. If handwriting analysis were a valid science, we would expect different experts to reach similar conclusions when presented with the same evidence. This is called “inter-rater reliability”, and is a crucial component of valid psychological science.

Correlation vs. Causation

While some studies have found correlations between certain handwriting features and personality traits, it’s important to remember that correlation doesn’t equal causation.

For example, a person with large handwriting might be more extroverted, but that doesn’t mean large handwriting causes extroversion or vice versa. These correlations could be due to other factors, such as cultural influences or writing education.

That said, even non-causal relationships can be useful if the goal of graphological analysis is simply to make inferences about an individual without regard for why.

The Brain-Hand Connection

While handwriting doesn’t seem to be able to tell us much about someone’s personality, there is solid research on how our brains (and their deterioration) can influence our handwriting.

For example, many people with neurological conditions like Parkinson’s disease present with micrographia https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6174397/ (small and cramped handwriting). As such, handwriting has been proposed as a biomarker for neurodegenerative diseases, allowing doctors to both diagnose it earlier and track its progression.

Handwriting Analysis 101: What Your Handwriting Says About You

Although we can’t endorse handwriting analysis as a scientifically valid method, understanding the basics can be a fun exercise. Here are some of the principles graphologists use:

1. Slant: Right-slanted writing is said to indicate an outgoing (or extroverted) personality, while left-slanted writing might suggest introversion.

2. Size: Large writing is associated with confidence, while small writing might indicate shyness.

3. Pressure: Heavy pressure could suggest high energy levels, while light pressure might indicate sensitivity.

4. Spacing: Wide spaces between words might indicate a need for freedom, while close spacing could suggest a desire for closeness.

5. Signature: A legible signature is said to indicate openness, while an illegible one might suggest a private nature.

Remember, these interpretations are not scientifically proven, so take them with a grain of salt!

What Are Examples of Handwriting Analysis Used in Court? (Case Studies)

Despite its lack of scientific validity with regards to personality prediction, handwriting analysis has proven useful in legal settings as forensic evidence.

Here are some notable examples:

1. The Lindbergh Kidnapping: https://www.fbi.gov/history/famous-cases/lindbergh-kidnapping In 1932, an intruder kidnapped aviator Charles Lindbergh’s infant son after leaving behind a ransom note on the windowsill. After chasing the trail of the bills eventually paid by the Lindbergh family, police were able to track down a certain Bruno Hauptmann. Handwriting experts then testified that Hauptmann’s handwriting matched the ransom notes, playing a key role in his capital sentencing.

2. The JonBenét Ramsey Case: https://bouldercolorado.gov/jonbenet-ramsey-homicide This unsolved case from 1996 involved the murder of 6-year-old beauty pageant JonBenét Ramsey. Although police initially suspected Ramsey’s parents, handwriting analysis of the lengthy ransom note left in the wake of her disappearance cleared them of guilt.

Unfortunately, the unreliability of graphology has also had some problematic consequences in the courtroom, perhaps best highlighted by the Dreyfus Affair. In 19th-century France, Alfred Dreyfus, a Jewish army officer, was wrongly convicted of treason based largely on handwriting evidence.

Years later, it was discovered that the handwriting actually matched that of another officer, Major Ferdinand Walsin Esterhazy. The case exposed the unreliability of handwriting analysis of the time and the influence of societal biases, leading to significant reforms in the French legal system.

Together, these cases highlight both the utility and shortcomings of handwriting in analysis in high-stakes situations. Although useful in some scenarios, the Dreyfus Affair underscores the need for more scientifically validated methods of graphology if we hope to continue using it in the legal realm.

What is Font Personality?

Font personality refers to the unique characteristics and qualities that people associate with different typefaces. Just as humans have personalities, fonts can be perceived as having distinct traits that influence how readers interpret and respond to written content.

Different fonts can trigger various emotional responses in readers. For example, one study in 2006 identified 5 main font personality factors:

• Serif fonts were perceived as stable, practical, mature and formal
• Sans-serif fonts were relatively neutral
• Script/funny fonts were seen as youthful, happy, creative, and casual
• Modern display fonts were perceived as masculine, assertive, and coarse
• Monospaced fonts were viewed as dull, plain, and conforming

What Are Some Scientifically Valid Personality Assessments?

So, if handwriting analysis isn’t exactly the most reliable way to make judgments about someone’s personality, what can we turn to?

And no, horoscopes aren’t the answer!

What you’re looking for is the Big Five (OCEAN) personality test. Grounded in decades of empirical research, the Big Five is the most validated, reliable, and widely accepted https://link.springer.com/referenceworkentry/10.1007/978-1-4419-1005-9_1226?sv1=affiliate&sv_campaign_id=101248&awc=26429_1729541738_002a6aa224c1b5daad875ac250ba3f86&utm_medium=affiliate&utm_source=awin&utm_campaign=CONR_BOOKS_ECOM_DE_PBOK_ALWYS_DEEPLINK&utm_content=textlink&utm_term=101248 model of personality in academic psychology.

The model assess five major personality traits:

• Openness: Reflects curiosity, creativity, and openness to new experiences and ideas.
• Conscientiousness: Indicates a tendency towards organization, dependability, and self-discipline.
• Extraversion: Measures sociability, assertiveness, and enthusiasm for social interactions.
• Agreeableness: Represents a tendency towards cooperation, compassion, and consideration for others.
• Neuroticism: Reflects emotional stability, anxiety levels, and sensitivity to stress.

All five traits have been found to be relatively stable throughout an individual’s life, supporting their validity as measures of enduring (and possibly innate) aspects of our personalities.

Are you curious about where you stand on the Big Five? Check out our free Big Five personality test here!

Master your People Skills

Create a Memorable PresenceCommunicate with ConfidenceAchieve Your Goals

Join People School

Have a question about the presentation or People School? Email Science of People support.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Handwriting Analysis

Can handwriting analysis accurately predict personality?

No, there is no scientific evidence that handwriting analysis can accurately predict personality. While graphologists claim they can deduce personality traits from handwriting, numerous studies have failed to find a consistent, reliable link between handwriting characteristics and personality. For reliable personality assessments, psychologists use scientifically validated tools like the Big Five personality test.

Can handwriting analysis predict future behavior?

No, there’s no scientific evidence that handwriting analysis can predict future behavior. While some graphologists claim they can foresee future actions based on handwriting, these claims are not supported by empirical research. Behavior is influenced by many complex factors that can’t be reliably predicted through handwriting alone.

Is handwriting analysis admissible in court?

While handwriting experts may testify in court, their testimony is often controversial and may be challenged. The admissibility of handwriting analysis in legal proceedings varies depending on the jurisdiction and the specific circumstances of the case. In some instances, it may be allowed as part of a broader body of evidence, but it’s generally not considered conclusive on its own.

Can handwriting analysis determine if someone is lying?

No, handwriting analysis cannot reliably detect deception. While some graphologists claim they can identify signs of dishonesty in handwriting, there’s no scientific evidence to support this. Detecting lies is a complex process that even trained professionals find challenging, and more established methods are generally considered more reliable.

Does changing your handwriting change your personality?

There’s no scientific evidence to support this claim. While some proponents of graphology suggest that altering your handwriting can influence your personality, this idea is not backed by research. Personality is a complex construct influenced by genetics, environment, and experiences, and it’s unlikely that simply changing how you form letters would have a significant impact on your fundamental personality traits.

Are there any valid uses for handwriting analysis?

While not scientifically validated for personality assessment, handwriting analysis has legitimate applications in forensic document examination and medical diagnostics. Forensic experts have used handwriting analysis to verify signatures and identify document authors in legal contexts, while changes in handwriting can serve as early indicators of neurodegenerative diseases like Parkinson’s, aiding in diagnosis.

How does handwriting analysis differ from signature analysis?

While both fall under the broader category of handwriting examination, signature analysis is generally considered more reliable, especially in forensic contexts. Signature analysis focuses on comparing known signatures to questioned ones, looking for consistencies and inconsistencies. This is often used in legal and financial settings to verify documents. Handwriting analysis, on the other hand, attempts to draw broader conclusions about personality from overall writing style, which is where its scientific validity is most questioned.

Is there any ongoing research into handwriting analysis?

While traditional graphology remains largely discredited in scientific circles, there is ongoing research into how handwriting relates to cognitive processes and motor skills. For example, studies are exploring how handwriting can be used as a diagnostic tool for certain neurological conditions or how it might reflect cognitive development in children. However, this research is distinct from the personality-focused claims of traditional graphology and is conducted using rigorous scientific methods.

Handwriting Analysis—Fascinating, but Not Factual

While handwriting analysis might be an intriguing conversation starter or a fun party trick, it falls short when it comes to scientific validity. To recap:

• Handwriting analysis, or graphology, claims to reveal personality traits through handwriting characteristics.
• It has a long history dating back to the 17th century and has been used in various fields, including criminal investigations and hiring processes.
• Scientific research has found little evidence to support graphology’s claims:
  • Lack of empirical evidence and inconsistent results among graphologists
  • The Barnum Effect explains why people might accept vague personality descriptions
  • Correlation doesn’t equal causation in observed relationships between handwriting and personality
  • While not valid for personality assessment, handwriting analysis can be useful in medical diagnostics for neurological conditions like Parkinson’s disease

If you want a more scientifically valid assessment of personality, the Big Five (OCEAN) model is what you’re looking for. There’s also the tried and true method of conversation and time spent together—and, surprisingly, face reading! Read our article for more: Face Reading, Analyzed: Everything You Ever Needed to Know